Reviewers recommend ordering a half size down.
Promising review: “These shoes are affordable, comfortable, and really cute! I had been looking for a loafer shoe, and these looked promising. They have a tiny heel that’s just right, so not completely flat and not too high. The pointed toe makes these more modern and dressy. I took into consideration other reviews on size. I normally wear an 8.5 up to a 9, especially in dress shoes. I went with an 8 and they fit perfect, despite having a wider width foot. I plan on regularly wearing them to work. I’ll update my review if they don’t hold up, but they seem decently made.” —Vans
Get them from Amazon for $34.99 (available in sizes 6-11 and in 35 styles).